VW ID Buzz Cargo long-term test | Fit for fleet

It would be easy to look at the ID Buzz Cargo’s sought-after Volkswagen badge, its concept van looks and electric powertrain and dismiss it by assuming it is too expensive and niche to consider for a fleet.

But the fact a number of major organisations, such as Wates Group and Mitie, have taken on the fully-electric LCV should show that, when all factors - including cost - are included, the ID Buzz Cargo should be considered as a serious workhorse.

Mitie also operates more than 600 Vauxhall Vivaro-e fully-electric vans – a range which is a leading example of a ‘typical’ fleet van - with a split of standard L1 and long L2 wheelbase versions.

But how does this fleet stalwart stack up against the Volkswagen van? For the purposes of our comparison, we will use the L1 Elite, which is closest to our ID Buzz Cargo Premium test model in terms of size and specification.

The Volkswagen is 4,712mm long and 2,211mm wide (including mirrors) compared to the Vauxhall’s 4,959mm and 2,204mm.

This means that if practicality is the ultimate consideration, then the larger Vivaro-e is the sensible choice.

At 5.3cu m, its loadspace volume is 26% larger than the ID Buzz Cargo’s 3.9cu m, while its 1,000kg payload is 41% greater than the Volkswagen’s 592kg.

The maximum dimensions of the Vivaro-e’s loadspace is 2,512mm long, (3,674mm using the load-through facility which is standard on Elite trim) 1,397mm high and 1,636mm wide, while the width between wheelarches is 1,258mm.

In comparison, the ID Buzz offers 2,208mm, 1,279mm, 1,732mm and 1,230mm respectively.

So, from a practicality point of view, it’s advantage Vivaro-e.

However, the ID Buzz Cargo offers a stronger cost proposition.

Not taking any manufacturer discounts into account, the Volkswagen has a retail price of £44,655 exc VAT, £3,547 less than the Vauxhall. Both are eligible for the Government’s £5,000 plug-in van grant.

The Van Running Cost tool on fleetnews.co.uk also shows the ID Buzz Cargo will cost much less to run: over a four-year/80,000-mile cycle, the Buzz will cost 38.17 pence per mile, with the Vivaro-e 51.92ppm.

Depreciation is the biggest contributor to this. At the end of the term, the ID Buzz Cargo will be worth £16,125; the Vivaro-e £7,300.

The ID Buzz Cargo will also cost less to ‘fuel’ as it is significantly more efficient. From its 77kW battery, the Volkswagen has an official WLTP range of 254 miles. From its slightly smaller 75kW battery, the Vauxhall manages only 196 miles.

The ID Buzz Cargo also takes much less time to charge. It has an onboard 11kW AC charger which means the battery can charge from empty to full in seven-and-a-half hours. The Vivaro-e has a 7kW charger (an 11kW unit is available as an option) and takes 11 hours and 20 minutes.

It is a similar story for DC charging. The Volkswagen can charge at up to 170kW, meaning it can take as little as 30 minutes to go from 5% to 80% capacity. The Vauxhall has the capability to take DC current at 100kW, taking 45 minutes to charge from 0% to 80%.

So what does all this analysis mean? Obviously organisations select vans primarily if they are fit-for-purpose, and the ID Buzz Cargo’s limitations from a practicality point of view may mean it is not suitable for some businesses.

But if the Volkswagen’s capabilities match up to a fleet’s operational requirements, then its costs and on-road capabilities make it worthy of serious consideration.

Loadspace and practicality

We’re into the second month of our time with the Volkswagen ID Buzz Cargo and, having used it for a variety of jobs, I now have a much greater understanding of its practicality.

We detailed the size of the loadspace and payload in our first report, but the van has since been used for a variety of jobs such as moving furniture, collecting paving slabs and transporting various other items, such as bicycles and bags of compost.

Loads can be securing using six lashing rings on the floor, as well as rails on the side walls. Our model is fitted with the standard rear wing doors, which can be opened to 180 degrees, while a wide-opening tailgate with a window is available as an option. Having sliding doors on both sides is a great boon.

Our test model is also fitted with the standard fixed bulkhead, which handily has two coat hooks mounted on it. The bulkhead is also available with an optional window and/or an opening through which items can be loaded.

This practicality, despite its concept car looks, means it is being taken seriously by some of the UK’s largest fleets: Mitie, for example, ordered 650 of them in February, fitted out with bespoke racking and other storage solutions, while Miele has also taken on a number of the models.

While the practicality of any van is key to fleet operations, any driver, of course, will spend a lot of time in the cabin and it’s hard to imagine that they would be anything other than very happy to be in the ID Buzz.

Build quality is high and while the materials are designed to be hardwearing – our van has covered just over 8,500 miles and the interior is as new – the integration of the same infotainment system, driver display panel and controls as the Volkswagen ID4, lifts it above general expectations.

This means the ID.Buzz’s gears are operated by the right steering wheel stalk (the left one controls the wipers and indicators/main beam) which frees up legroom for the centre-seat passenger.

Despite this, it is still a squeeze to fit three normal-sized adults in the cabin, making the middle seat more suitable for children or for shorter journeys only.

There is also plenty of storage: there are two cabin-width bins on the top of the dashboard between the steering wheel and windscreen, a number of other cubby holes as well as a handy compartment to the left of the steering wheel for a mobile phone which also has two USB-C ports.

The cabin also has two other USB-C charging ports and a 12-volt socket. Our vehicle is also fitted with the optional (£408) 230-volt three-pin socket located on the frame underneath the passenger seat.

I had hoped this would draw power from the main traction battery so I would be able to power appliances such a pressure washer from it, but disappointingly (for me) it doesn’t. Instead, it takes it from the 12V battery and has a 300W output, making it suitable for much lighter duties, such as charging laptops.

We’ll look at the running cost data and real-world efficiency more in the next report, but from a practicality and driver well-being perspective, the ID Buzz continues to look like a winner.

VW ID Buzz Cargo joins our fleet

One of the first things I noticed after getting behind the wheel of our new long-term Volkswagen ID Buzz Cargo van was the enormous amount of attention it attracts.

I’ve had people point at it, wander over to it to have a closer look as soon as I’ve parked it, while pedestrians and other motorists often stare at it when I drive past them.

I’m sure part of that is because of the Commerce Plus (basic price of £43,875, exc VAT) trim level model’s vibrant Lime Yellow metallic colour, but also because of the retro-futuristic styling which harks back to the iconic 1950s Volkswagen T1 van.

However, the ID Buzz Cargo’s appeal is much more than just skin deep. Underneath the striking exterior is a capable van.

At 4.7m long, it sits between the Caddy (4.5m) and shortest Transporter (4.9m), and offers a load space of 3.9cu m (Caddy: 3.7cu m; Transporter short wheelbase/normal roof: 4.3cu m), with Volkswagen saying it can carry two Euro pallets. Payload is 592kg.

The ID Buzz Cargo’s maximum load length is 2.2m, with a maximum loading width of 1.7m. The distance between the wheel arches – which is also the same as the rear door opening - is 1.23m. It has sliding doors on both sides, as well as having rear doors which can open 180 degrees.

The van is based on the Volkswagen Group’s MEB platform, which is also used for a number of passenger cars such as the Volkswagen ID4, Audi Q4 e-tron and Cupra Born.

ID Buzz Cargo also uses the same 204PS motor, rear-wheel drive layout, as some of those, while its 77kWh battery provides a WLTP range of 254 miles.

The onboard charger technology is also shared with the cars, and this means the van can charge at speeds of up to 170kW from a DC charger, taking 30 minutes for the battery to go from 5% to 80% capacity.

A maximum rate of 11kW from an AC charger will see it take seven-and-a-half hours to go from empty to full.

Over the next few months we’ll be reporting on life with the ID Buzz Cargo, but there has been plenty to like about it so far.

Its car origins are clear in the way it drives, while much of its standard safety and comfort equipment is shared across the VW Group vehicles.

In particular, the navigation and infotainment system will be recognised by anyone familiar with the ID3 and ID4, and features a 5.5-inch driver display panel and a 10-inch centrally-mounted touchscreen.

As mentioned earlier, the positive impression it has made so far with the wider public has been clear – and that level of enthusiasm has been more than matched by me.